Skip to content

SSL cert for https://downloads.vscodium.com is signed by invalid authority #2288

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open
2 tasks done
trisweb opened this issue Mar 30, 2025 · 25 comments
Open
2 tasks done
Labels
bug Something isn't working

Comments

@trisweb
Copy link

trisweb commented Mar 30, 2025

Describe the bug
The current SSL certificate for https://downloads.vscodium.com was created on March 29th, 2025, and expires on the same in 2026, however the certificate authority is invalid and untrusted by most clients.

"net::ERR_CERT_AUTHORITY_INVALID"

Please confirm that this problem is VSCodium-specific

  • This bug doesn't happen if I use Microsoft's Visual Studio Code. It only happens in VSCodium.

Please confirm that the issue/resolution isn't already documented

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Go to https://download.vscodium.com
  2. Observe net::ERR_CERT_AUTHORITY_INVALID certificate security error

Alternatively, update from the mirrored debian repository hosted on https://download.vscodium.com/ and see error:

E: Failed to fetch https://download.vscodium.com/debs/dists/vscodium/InRelease Clearsigned file isn't valid, got 'NOSPLIT' (does the network require authentication?)
E: The repository 'https://download.vscodium.com/debs vscodium InRelease' is no longer signed.
N: Updating from such a repository can't be done securely, and is therefore disabled by default.

Expected behavior
Self-expanatory

Edit Apr-5: I had "downloads" rather than download above, so when testing still received an invalid cert. Updating for posterity.

@trisweb trisweb added the bug Something isn't working label Mar 30, 2025
@trisweb trisweb changed the title SSL cert for https://downloads.vscodium.com has expired SSL cert for https://downloads.vscodium.com is signed by invalid authority Mar 30, 2025
@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Mar 30, 2025

@PalinuroSec

@bdube
Copy link

bdube commented Mar 30, 2025

The vscodium.com domain appears to have expired and DNS NS has switched from registrar-servers.com to bodis.com.

@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Mar 30, 2025

Not good at all! I've sent an email to @PalinuroSec. (He has the control on the domain name and he's the team leader of ParrotSec)

@bdube Thx for catching the domain name expiration...

@Beeblebrox21
Copy link

Image - looks like the domain has gone away ...

@strasharo
Copy link

The domain now appears to be blocked by the ADGuard list.

@cadusilva
Copy link

The domain now appears to be blocked by the ADGuard list.

Not the domain itself, but the CNAME it points to (bodis.com), as it's a monetization service.

@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Mar 31, 2025

bodis.com is a parking service which is used since the domain name is its grace period.

Last year, we had the same issue, it took several days to get it sorted out (#1840)
I've already asked if I can buy the domain name.

@devloberto
Copy link

Oops, I created a kind of duplicate:
VSCodium/vscodium.github.io#96

@madeddy
Copy link

madeddy commented Mar 31, 2025

Last year, we had the same issue...

So we can expect one or more repetitions in the future. This bodes well.

@daiyam daiyam marked this as a duplicate of #2291 Mar 31, 2025
@mbnoimi
Copy link

mbnoimi commented Apr 1, 2025

still occurs!

W: Failed to fetch https://download.vscodium.com/debs/dists/vscodium/InRelease  Could not connect to download.vscodium.com:443 (199.59.243.228). - connect (113: No route to host)

@Macleykun
Copy link

bodis.com is a parking service which is used since the domain name is its grace period.

Last year, we had the same issue, it took several days to get it sorted out (#1840) I've already asked if I can buy the domain name.

Just a bit curious, but how could this happen? Is automatic domain renewal not activated maybe?

@PalinuroSec
Copy link
Contributor

we had an issue with out card that refused all the renewals for our infra, including the vscodium domain.

maintaining the domain and the download cdn for this project is a form of donation i'm committed to and a reason to be proud of, but these small incidents have a big impact to the project and i'm very sorry for that.

now the domain got renewed correctly and works again for me, please let me know if the new records are working again for you as well.

p.s.
i would like to remind you that i am not the owner of this project, and the actual owners are free to ask for the domain transfer code whenever they like.

@PalinuroSec
Copy link
Contributor

Just a bit curious, but how could this happen? Is automatic domain renewal not activated maybe?

yes, auto-renewal is on. the reason why the payment was declined is to be investigated, as the balance was there and the renewal went well the previous years.

also we got no email alert from namecheap except for one message that went to spam for failed domain verification

@trisweb
Copy link
Author

trisweb commented Apr 1, 2025

Thanks @PalinuroSec, it happens.

I'd chip in for 5 years if you want to just put some insurance on it for a while.

@PalinuroSec
Copy link
Contributor

that would be nice.
actually i was thinking of moving the domain off namecheap and migrate it to infomaniak, where it would be possible to create an organization just for vscodium and allow multiple people to manage its assets, so to avoid single points of failure

@Macleykun
Copy link

Macleykun commented Apr 1, 2025

that would be nice. actually i was thinking of moving the domain off namecheap and migrate it to infomaniak, where it would be possible to create an organization just for vscodium and allow multiple people to manage its assets, so to avoid single points of failure

Another one I can recommend is porkbun! It also has the ability to share the access with other users :) !
Source: https://kb.porkbun.com/article/242-subaccounts-vs-authorized-users

@daiyam daiyam marked this as a duplicate of #2295 Apr 1, 2025
@nindogo
Copy link

nindogo commented Apr 1, 2025

maintaining the domain and the download cdn for this project is a form of donation i'm committed to and a reason to be proud of, but these small incidents have a big impact to the project and i'm very sorry for that.

Hi all,

  1. Currently in Kenya — my updates are going through. It may take a few more moments but I am sure in time all people will be able to access the domain.

(But it is unstable

dnf install marble

Updating and loading repositories:
download.vscodium.com 100% | 716.0 B/s | 2.2 KiB | 00m03s
Librepo error: repomd.xml GPG signature verification error: Error during parsing OpenPGP packets

  1. VSCode is so good that people using vscodium will be many.
  2. Namecheap may be good but maybe there are better solutions — and this is a political/religious/editor war level argument.
  3. xkcd was right

That said I see @trisweb has committed to fund 5 years of domain registration — could you/@VSCodium consider a project/foundation/parent group to actually collect even lower donations and track them so that this never happens again (while VScode is relevant). Maybe even @microsoft would be open to support it?

@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Apr 2, 2025

For those interested, I've made a new repo for Linux. Please read #2296. Thx

@madeddy
Copy link

madeddy commented Apr 5, 2025

... migrate it to infomaniak, where it would be possible... allow multiple people to manage its assets, so to avoid single points of failure

Another one...porkbun! It also has the ability to share the access with other users...

Thats IMO the most logical idea so far to smooth stuff out and security. I see for now only advantages if we don't ask for the price.

@trisweb
Copy link
Author

trisweb commented Apr 5, 2025

Checking back on this.

I see vscodium.com is back, and download.vscodium.com now works again as well.

Reiterating my offer to contribute to a longer domain renewal, but I'm happy to wait until the domain is in the right home. Or whatever is easiest if there's already a general donation process. Thanks!

@sedrubal
Copy link

sedrubal commented Apr 5, 2025

For those interested, I've made a new repo for Linux.

I'm wondering why you created a new repository. It seems that you are part of the vscodium team. IMHO there should be only one trustworthy repository under a trustworthy domain. I mean thanks for your effort, but users can't rely on any random repository that pops up when the main one breaks. Sorry for being so negative. I'm very grateful for all the work behind vscodium, but it seems that the domain ownership is quite chaotic and I'm wondering if we can trust the project, after all we have seen that happened to liblzma / xz.

@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Apr 5, 2025

@sedrubal I understand the problem.

But as I said, vscodium.com is owned and controlled by @PalinuroSec which is the team leader of ParrotSec. I don't think there is any security issue there.

For me, it has been 4 years that I'm the main maintainer and I'm not hidden behind a false name.
The source code of the project are available The binaries are fully generated by the GitHub Actions (to avoid any shenigans).
So you are free to audit the project and make your own opinion 😉

I've built the new repository because:

  • recurrent downtime with the CDN and domain name (when not paid)
  • the old repository doesn't support all the platforms due to file limitations of GitLab (same as for GitHub)
  • I control vscodium.dev (so if there is any issue I can act on it)

@PalinuroSec
Copy link
Contributor

why don't we let both vscodium.com and vscodium.dev point to github pages and mirror the same content? we might even do the same for the repository by using the gitlab artifacts pages? both github and gitlab already provide their assets through a CDN, so we could avoid paying for an extra layer yet preserving the same domain functionality

@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Apr 7, 2025

why don't we let both vscodium.com and vscodium.dev point to github pages and mirror the same content?

Yep, I was thinking the same.

we might even do the same for the repository by using the gitlab artifacts pages?

Currently, the gitlab repo can't include the arm32 version due to the limitation of 1GB for GitLab Pages. All the .deb and .rpm amount to 1.4GB

@daiyam
Copy link
Member

daiyam commented Apr 19, 2025

  • recurrent downtime with the CDN and domain name (when not paid)

#2332

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
bug Something isn't working
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests