Rollback Analysis: What We'd Lose vs. What We'd Gain

[DerekRoberts]

🔍 Rollback Analysis: Commit #268 vs. Current State

After our troubleshooting attempts failed to resolve the pinning issues, we're considering a rollback to commit #268 (August 26) to restore a working configuration.

📊 What We'd Lose (Additional commits since #268):

🚫 Broken/Problematic Features (Good to Lose):

• v1 Migration Attempts (fix: change datasource to github-tags for unversioned references #281-288) - 8 failed attempts that never worked
• Regex Manager Experiments (fix: add currentValue capture group to customManagers regex #272-280) - 9 broken attempts at custom managers
• Critical Preset Loading Issues (fix: resolve critical preset loading issue and simplify validation workflow #256, Revert "fix: resolve critical preset loading issue and simplify validation workflow" #258) - Multiple failed fixes
• Recent Pinning Failures (fix: prevent SHA pinning of trusted GitHub Actions #295-300) - 6 broken pinning attempts
• Container Unpinning Rules (chore: remove ineffective container unpinning rules #290) - Ineffective Docker image handling
• Package Rule Cleanup (chore: remove redundant rules and simplify configuration #292-293) - Removal of redundant rules
• Ecosystem Groupings (feat: comprehensive Renovate configuration optimization and ecosystem groupings #294) - Grouping rules for different package types

⚠️ Potentially Valuable Features (Might Want to Keep):

• Regex Pattern Simplification (fix: simplify regex patterns in rules-actions.json5 #260) - Cleaner action rules
• Preset Loading Workflow (fix: resolve critical preset loading issue and simplify validation workflow #255) - Validation workflow improvements
• Unversioned References Fix (fix: use unversioned references in default.json for main branch compatibility #262) - Main branch compatibility
• Development Files Cleanup (chore: remove development files and junk #264) - Junk removal

🔧 Infrastructure Improvements:

• Release Workflow Fixes (fix: preserve patch tags in release workflow and add error handling #254) - Patch tag preservation and error handling
• Package Consistency (fix: package name consistency and config improvements #267) - Naming improvements
• Immortal PR Prevention (fix: add global recreateWhen: conflicted to prevent immortal PRs #266) - Global recreateWhen setting

💡 Recovery Strategy:

Since the PRs still exist, we can selectively cherry-pick the valuable features back after restoring the working configuration. This gives us:

1. Immediate stability - Working configuration restored
2. Selective recovery - Bring back only the features that actually work
3. Clean slate - No more broken functionality to troubleshoot

🎯 Next Steps:

1. Get some sleep - This has been painful and frustrating
2. Rollback to refactor: simplify prerelease blocking rule #268 - Restore working configuration (August 26 state)
3. Assess what to recover - Cherry-pick valuable features one by one
4. Test each addition - Ensure we don't break what's working again

📝 Key Lesson:

When we have a working configuration, we should be much more cautious about making changes. The working setup from August 26 was probably simpler and more reliable than what we've built since.

🔄 Final Rollback Target:

Rolling back to #268 would lose about 40+ commits but most are failed experiments. The working configuration from August 26 should be much more stable than what we have now.

Commit #268 was a simple prerelease blocking rule simplification - minimal, working change that gives us a solid foundation.

---

Updated after deciding to rollback to commit #268 (August 26)